TDS and Tax Liability in India

1. What is the basis of taxability of income of any person in India?

Ans.

The taxability of income of any person in India is generally based on his/her Residential Status (RS) and scope of total income determined based on the said RS under the Income-tax Act, 1961 (IT Act) and Double Tax Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) entered between India and country of residence of the said person.


As per the IT Act, the RS of an individual may be classified in any one of the following (Refer FAQs on Residential Status to understand how RS is determined under the IT Act): 

·         Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR)  

·         Resident and Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR)

·         Non-Resident (NR)


Further, the scope of total income which is chargeable to tax in India is based on the RS of the above individual, which is explained in the ensuing questions. 

2. What is the scope of total income chargeable to tax of a NRI in India?

Ans.

Following income earned by NRI is liable to tax in India:

a.   Income earned from any source in India is taxable in India i.e. Income which accrues or arises in India and is deemed to accrue or arise in India eg:- Interest income from investments in India; Capital Gains from investments in India; Income from Immovable Property located in India;

b.   Any other income received or deemed to be received in India; and


Any income other than above may not be taxable in India.


Further, NRI may take recourse to DTAA between India and his country of residence to evaluate if there is any benefit/relief available under DTAA, while determining the scope of total income and taxability of income thereof.

3. What is the scope of total income chargeable to tax of a RNOR/Deemed Resident in India?

Ans.

Following income earned by RNOR is liable to tax in India:

a.   Income earned from any source in India is taxable in India i.e. Income which accrues or arises in India and is deemed to accrue or arise in India eg:-; Interest income from Investments in India; Capital Gains from investments in India; and Income from Immovable Property located in India;

b.    Any other income received or deemed to be received in India; and

c.    Income earned outside India from business controlled or profession set-up in India

Any income other than above may not be taxable in India.

Further, a person who qualifies as a Deemed Resident of India is considered as RNOR under the IT Act and their scope of total income is determined in the same manner as RNOR, as explained above. Refer FAQ no. 4 on “Residential Status” for conditions to qualify as “Deemed Resident”. 

4. What is the Income tax liability of a ROR in India?

Ans.

He/she shall be liable to tax in India on his/her global income. However, if any foreign source income is taxed in both India as well as in the source country, he/she may be eligible to claim credit of foreign taxes paid on foreign income in the foreign country as per provisions of the IT Act and DTAA between India and foreign country. Refer FAQ on DTAA.


5. What are the slab rates applicable in case of taxable income earned by a NRI for the FY 2024-25 and whether any beneficial slab rate is available to NRI senior citizen?

Ans.

Income earned by a NRI is taxable at slab rate (except for certain special income which is taxed at special rate). An option is provided to the NRI who is not earning business income to either be governed by new tax regime or old tax regime, whichever is beneficial for him. Different slab rate of tax is provided in New Tax Regime and Old Tax Regime and details of which along with comparison between both the regime are explained in the ensuing paragraphs. From FY 2024-25 onwards, the new tax regime is set as the default option. If anyone wants to continue with the old regime, he/she is required to opt for it at the time of filing the ROI.


·     The slab rates applicable to NRI individual under new tax regime and old tax regime is tabulated below:

Total Income

Tax Rate under Old Tax Regime

Total Income

Tax Rate under New Tax Regime

Upto Rs. 2,50,000/- (basic exemption limit)

NIL

Upto Rs. 3,00,000/- (basic exemption limit)

NIL

Rs. 2,50,001/- to 5,00,000/-

5%

Rs.3,00,001/- to 7,00,000/-

5%

Rs. 5,00,001/- to 10,00,000/-

20%

Rs.7,00,001/- to 10,00,000/-

10%

Above Rs. 10,00,000/-

30%

Rs.10,00,001/- to 12,00,000/-

15%



Rs.12,00,001/- to 15,00,000/-

20%



Above 15,00,000/-

30%

 

·    Higher basic exemption limit is available in case of resident senior citizen. However, if the senior citizen is an NRI, such higher basic exemption limit is not available and slab rates tabulated above will continue to apply to all NRI individuals including senior citizens.


·    The new tax regime provides beneficial slab rates. However, the taxpayer loses certain deductions under the said regime. The comparison of some important deductions available under both regimes (FY 2024-25) is tabulated below:


Nature of deduction

Old Tax Regime

New Tax Regime

Deduction under Chapter VI A (Refer FAQs to understand the deductions available under Chapter VIA), eg:

80C – LIC 

80D – Mediclaim premium

80G – Donation

80TTA – Deduction for interest from savings account

ü   

X

Exemption of income of Minor

ü   

X

Interest on home loan– self- occupied or vacant property

ü   

X

Interest on home loan– let out property i.e. property given on rent

ü   

ü   

Family Pension

ü   

ü   

House Rent Allowance (i.e. deduction for rent paid)

ü   

X

Leave Travel Allowance 

ü   

X

Personal Allowances (i.e. children education allowance, allowance granted to meet hostel expenditure of his child, allowance to meet cost of travel on tour, expenditure for purchase of uniform, expenditure incurred on helper etc.)

ü   

X

Deduction of payment of professional tax

ü   

X

Standard deduction of Rs. 50,000 from salaries

ü   

ü

Set off of loss carried forward attributable to any of deductions referred above

ü   

X


·     Surcharge Rates: Further, the surcharge rate for FY 2024-25 under both the regime is given below:

 

Income

Rate of Surcharge

Effective tax rates after surcharge and Cess**

Rs. 50 lakhs to Rs. 1 Crore

10%

34.32%

Rs. 1 crore to Rs. 2 crores

15%

35.88%

Rs. 2 crores to Rs. 5 crores*

25%

39%

Above Rs. 5 crores – New Tax regime

25%

39%

Above Rs. 5 crores – Old Tax regime

37%

42.74%


* Provided that in case where total income includes dividend income from shares or long-term capital gain on transfer of capital assets and short term capital gain on transfer of equity share in a company or a unit of an equity oriented fund or a unit of a business trust, rate of surcharge on amount of Income-tax computed in respect of that part of income shall not exceed 15% and in that case effective tax rate after surcharge and cess shall be 35.88%.

**Health and Education cess shall be levied at the rate of 4% payable on income-tax and surcharge.

Marginal tax rate relief on surcharge is available i.e. a relief will be provided to certain taxpayers up to the amount of the difference between the excess tax payable (including surcharge) on the income above prescribed limit and the amount of income that exceeds such prescribed limit.

6. When Indian income of a NRI is taxed in both India as well as in the country of his residence as per domestic tax laws of respective countries, what recourse is available to NRI from such double taxation of income?

Ans.

In the given case, it is seen that there may be double taxation of same income. In such a situation, one may take recourse to DTAA between India and his country of residence to evaluate if there is any benefit/relief available under DTAA. For detailed understanding refer FAQ on DTAA. As a last recourse, taxes paid on such income in the source country [i.e. India, in the present case] can be claimed as credit while paying taxes in the Resident country as per DTAA between India and country of residence of NRI and/or as per domestic tax laws of the Resident Country of NRI subject to satisfaction of terms and conditions as mentioned therein.

 

Further, please note India has recently signed the Multilateral Convention to implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (commonly referred to as Multilateral Instrument-MLI) along with representatives of many countries. It’s provisions will be applicable on India’s DTAAs from FY 2020-21 so as to act as a deterrent to tax evasion strategies and curb revenue loss through treaty abuse and base erosion and profit shifting strategies.

7. What are the withholding tax rates (ie. Tax Deducted at Source, TDS rates) and Income tax rates applicable to a NRI arising on income earned in India for the FY 2023-24? Further, can NRI avail benefit of basic exemption limit or claim Chapter VI-A deduction against any source of income?

Ans.

The TDS and Income tax rates applicable to NRIs as per the provisions of the IT Act is outlined in below table along with the source of income against which NRI can avail basic exemption limit or claim deduction under Chapter VI-A, subject to the provisions of DTAA which generally override the provisions of the IT act as per the option/choice of the taxpayer. Accordingly, NRIs can take recourse of beneficial rates (if any) applicable to them under DTAA between India and NRI’s country of residence as in which case the below rates will be revised as per DTAA rates.

Sr. No.

 

Type of Asset and Source of Income

 

Chapter VI-A Deduction available

Benefit of basic exemption

Basic rate under the Act
(plus applicable Cess and Surcharge)

 

 

Income tax rate (Note 1)

TDS (Note 1 and 2)

 

I

Immovable Property

 

 

 

 

 

 

A

Rent

Yes

Yes

Slab Rate

30%

 

B

LTCG

(Before 23 July 2024)

No

No

20%

(With Indexation Benefit)

20%

 

C

LTCG

(On or After 23 July 2024)

No

No

12.5%

(Without Indexation)

12.5%

 

 

D

Short Term Capital Gains (STCG)

Yes

Yes

Slab Rate

30%

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

II

Bank Accounts / Fixed Deposits/ Public Provident Fund (PPF)/ Tax free bonds

 

 

 

 

 

A

Interest on NRO a/c

Yes

Yes

Slab Rate

30%